Saturday, September 18, 2010

DREDGING SAND IN AKULAM KAYAL

DREDGING SAND IN AKULAM KAYAL

THRIVIKRAMJI@GMAIL.COM

As part of the Malayalam news bulletin, an interesting report with visuals of piled up sand was on the screen of my TV in the Kairali channel this morning at 7:00 am. I saw the blue and striped kurta wearing image of Thomas Issac also somewhere along. The voilce over said about 1 laks tons of sand now recovered as part of the program of cleaning the Kayal. This sand dredging or recovery of construction sand was part of the project launched by the Travancore cements or someone like them. There is also a plan in Thiruvallom too to go for dredging.

1. Only point I want to bring to public notice is that the sand pile in Akkulam and that might come up in Thiruvallam are part of ancient beach deposits. In fact the google earth image I am attaching will add science to my sentences. Once up on a time our seashore in Trivandrum was like to the east of Attukal Temple, Thampanoor, Pettah, Anayara and toward north further, i.e., far inaland of the modern shoreline. The Veli Hills (ridge) formed the northern boundary of the embayment, while the southern boundary of this “bay” was along the Thiruvallom Hills, whose northern edge of the latter is skirted by the Kaimanam Thiruvallom road. The drainage course were also active in that deeper time.

2. As time went by like around 4000 -4500 years ago, the sea reached the present position by a relative fall in the sealevel converting the entire bay like area into land. The Akkulam kayal is the channel for the drainage from the hinterland of Trivandrum (most of the present city) and the monsoon discharge maintained the channel that is cut through the ancient fill of sea or beach sand.

3. When the co-op bank building, east of “Padmatheerthom”, foundation was tested, before construction of the structure, some kind of drilling was employed to get samples of the substrate and it so happened a piece darkgray clay sample, recovered from the boreholes, landed on my office desk, for verification of the sediment type. But what also attracted my attention was the presence of foraminiferal tests – fossils of a marine micro-organism. To me it was the sure hint for the existence of western sea behind the Eastfort Bust Station. A s geologist, I will extend that sea to all the land at the elevation of Eastfort bus stand.

4. When the TTP wanted an extra source/supply of water the CGWB (Central Ground Water Board) was requested for help, who advised sinking of two large diameter wells in their campus at Veli. The exploratory work revealed presence of a thin limestone layer in the TTP compound to the western side of the Kochuveli Train station. This is a “smoking pistol” in so far as the presence of the western sea inside the modern land area in coastal Trivandrum. In fact, between the headlands formed by the Veli Hills of VSSC to the north and the Thiruvallom Hills in the south, there existed a large bay like extension of the modern sea, which gradually got filled in with sea and beach sediments. However, the drainages along the Akkulam kayal and the Karamana ar continued to exist and were maintained by the monsoon discharge from the land area in the east. This patch of todays land and some water courses, is in fact a reservoir of 1000s of millions of beach sand, which geoscientists will designate as ancient beach alluviam.

5. Say 4000-4500 yr ago B(efore)P(resent), the Akulam kayal basin and Karamana ar mouth were somewhere far landward of the modern shoreline, which gradually migrated toward the modern shoreline, through and over a substrate of beach sand brought in by the waves and currents of the western sea. Therefore we can dredge and get sand from the shallow waters, and if dredged somewhat deeper we will also come across the limestone reported by the CGWB from the TTP compound. As one went deep into landward the limestone has changed or “morphed” in to marine fossil bearing dark-gray shale (shale is a fine clay rich rock) that appeared in the subsurface underneath the co-op bank building at the East fort.

6. So what is the point of this note. Firstly it is no surprise to have hit the mother lode of sand. The geohistory has it that way. Secondly it is not construction grade coarser sand instead it is medium to fine beach sand and in fact ancient beach sand. Further, the volume of shell and shell fragments in the sand may be deleterious for the proposed end use.

7. I am unsure whether or not any mandatory clearance of any sort is required for changing the bottom-scape or bottom topography of the Akkulam kayal, which has a shoreline richly endowed with several important mangrove plant species. Once the kayal bed is deepened by dredging and removal of sediment, the shore sediment at equilibrium with the original kayal floor will get disturbed and the only means of reestablishing a new equilibrium will be by subaqueous slumping which will affect the modern shoreline and everything practically living attached to the shore sediment. The mangroves are no exception to this law of nature.

8. I am not sure if any scientific outfit of the government ever gave clearance for this sort of dredging sand from the kayal or river bed. The scientific approval is important in issues like this, unlike the so called administrative approvals where the scientific input is limited to the science of paper making and the software.

----------------

MADE TODDY AND ANTIQUE GOVT POLICY

MADE TODDY AND ANTIQUE GOVT POLICY

thrivikramji@gmail.com

It is time for the general public to assail the state’s policy of the distribution of several lakhs of rupees to the members of the affected families soon after the strike of a spurious liquor or made toddy tragedy resulting in loss of life, blinding or maiming.

In fact, instead of piping out the tax payer’s money from the coffers of the state, the concerned dealer or contractor has to be made responsible for the tragic deaths and they should be made to pay off the compensation fixed by govt.

I suggest some other alternatives. For e.g., look at the third party insurance in respect of motor cars/lorries etc. It is a process that is time tested and well run all over the world. There is an analogy here. The compensation can come out of an insurance of some sort paid for by the promoter of the toddy/liquor business.

Think of this one. There is already a toddy tappers welfare fund. What about a toddy drinkers welfare fund of some sort. Think outside of the box. The ministers can only offer wads of currency to the families of the diseased and suffering victims. It is for the rest of the society to think in terms of containing the risk and reducing the risk due to some evil minded trader of spurious toddy/liquor making quick money.

Or this one too, i.e., some sort of a group insurance scheme offered by the dealer to the drinkers. The life of toddy drinkers must stand insured against an event of tragic and accidental death due to consumption of spurious toddy or liquor. The financial aid will come to the rescue of the survivors of the family from the insurance company. The trader will pay the insurance cover anyway. Something like an insurance cover we buy before we board a flight. Here instead of the buyer, the seller will have to pay for the insurance.

I would also go to the extent of suggesting introduction of a billing system carrying the name and address of the buyer so that in the event of a tragic end, the buyer and seller are easily located to settle the claims. It is also a mechanism by which more income tax payers can be brought under the tax net.

Our police department once a while posts large bill boards listing death statistics on the roadside to remind the drivers about the risks human life is exposed to in the highways and other roads. Why not a similar system of display in all the shops trading liquor and toddy loudly and boldly announcing the number of deaths or maiming due to sale and consumption of spurious toddy/liquor.

Similarly how about executing a written undertaking by the dealer/contractor stating that in the event of a death due to the consumption of the stuff sold by the dealer in one or other of his outlets, he will promptly pay off the compensation to the victim’s dependents and at the rate fixed by the government from time to time.

Such a revolutionary thinking needs to be introduced to save the lives of some citizens as well as to secure the future of the affected families. If the govt can make money out of the sale of business rights for a decent fee why not measures such as the above or any others better than these to avoid the tragedies in future.

-------------

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Toddy Tragedy:Malappuram, India

The surprising thing to me about the Chittur area of Palkkad Dist is the profuse source of toddy resident either on the surface or on the subsurface there. The Regulating f agenfcy designated for movement of toddy is the excise department. In fact they issue permit for moving toddy from Chitrtur any other part of the state.

What I am blank about is the source of toddy, the off take volume per day, number of trees that are harvested for toddy. In fact, there is a system of keeping a tab on the number of trees tapped and the book keeper is the excise department of the state.

Luckily, if investigated one would find a correlation between the off take and use in Chittur on the one hand and the number of trees designated for tapping toddy by the government agency. After all even the gods open their mind and eyes at the sight of wads of currency note.

In such a society, what about the mortals who work for the government. What is needed to investigate is the beeline of beneficiaries out of the made toddy in the district.

After all the government pays away Rs.65 lakhs per live lost. But the money comes from the exchequer just like the pay and salaries of the government employees.

The memory is absolutely short and until the next tragedy lands people involved will go about freely doing their ways of doing things.

In fact the made toddy saved the govt from the lottery scam.
The Minister in charge Gurudasan found a solace in the fact that TN has 6000 shops doing the business while Kerala has far fewer and statistically Kerala record is better than what TN has.Three cheers for the minister for this achievement.t